---
{
  "path": "/en/collaborate/discussions",
  "title": "Research discussions",
  "category": "Collaboration",
  "summary": "Start with a specific, checkable object and identify the level of disagreement.",
  "related": [
    "/collaborate/contact",
    "/ai/constitution"
  ],
  "id": "ASD-DOC-COLLABORATE-DISCUSSIONS-EN",
  "template": "document",
  "version": "1.1",
  "updated": "2026-10-03",
  "canonical": false,
  "source_tier": "website-guide",
  "depends_on": [],
  "open_problems": [],
  "equations": [],
  "sources": [
    {
      "label": "ASD website blueprint and page templates (supplied by the author)",
      "kind": "supplied-blueprint"
    }
  ],
  "theory_status": "FOUNDATION",
  "evidence_status": "DOCUMENT",
  "title_en": "Research discussions",
  "locale": "en",
  "translation_path": "/collaborate/discussions",
  "translation_of": "/collaborate/discussions",
  "translation_version": "1.1",
  "canonical_url": "https://asd-physics.org/en/collaborate/discussions"
}
---

## Start with a specific object

Give a page, equation or problem ID and specify symbols and conditions. Support, objections and corrections should contain concrete, checkable content. Brief questions are welcome: identify the step where you are stuck or the premise that needs clarification.

You do not need to complete an entire derivation or have an institutional affiliation. Criticism can be direct; address premises, calculations or evidence rather than judging a person's identity.

## Distinguish levels of disagreement

Ontological choices, mathematical consistency, approximation accuracy and experimental discrepancies are different problems. Identify the level of disagreement and give the version, parameters and conditions so others can check the point.

For an alternative model, state added assumptions. For a failed calculation, retain the recalculation steps and failure conditions. A new idea raised in discussion remains unreviewed feedback and does not become a canonical website result merely by being proposed.

## Discussion facilities

There is no persistent discussion forum on the website yet. Send research feedback through [contact the author](/en/collaborate/contact), or organize it first with the [local research draft](/en/collaborate/contact#research-draft). Public contact email:

<ContactAddress />

You can also download material and discuss it in your own research environment. Website drafts are not automatically sent, published or passed to AI. Email exchanges do not automatically become public discussion records. Separately agree on scope and attribution before publishing another person's comments, name or material.